Personal Jurisdiction in Trump’s BBC Defamation Lawsuit

President Trump has sued the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) in federal court in Florida for defamation and violations of Florida’s consumer protection statute. This case, too, makes a nice review for civil procedure students looking ahead to a final examination, especially in classes that covered personal jurisdiction in defamation cases. Trump’s lawsuit arises out of a 2024 BBC documentary in which two distinct parts of a speech by Trump were spliced together.  The BBC acknowledges that the edits “gave the mistaken impression” that Trump made a direct call for violence. The chairman of the BBC also explicitly acknowledged the editing “error” and apologized to Trump.

The court dismissed the consumer protection claim for failure to state a claim, but not the defamation claim, which left the question of whether the court had personal jurisdiction over the BBC on that claim. The case, President Donald J. Trump v. British Broadcasting Corp., is interesting not just as an exercise for students reviewing personal jurisdiction, but also because courts have struggled with the “purposeful availment” part of the due process test in tort cases in which the “effects” of the tortious conduct are felt in the forum state when the connections are generated by internet-related activity (as is partially true in this case). In my view, Judge Kuntz was correct that the court had personal jurisdiction, but he was saddled with an unconvincing test articulated by the Eleventh Circuit in Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Mosseri (2013).

Personal Jurisdiction and Purposeful Availment

Under the Supreme Court’s case law on Fourteenth Amendment due process (applicable here pursuant to FRCP 4(k)(1)(A)), the defendant is subject to specific jurisdiction if (1) it “purposefully avail[ed] itself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum State,” (2) the claim arises out of or relates to the defendant’s contacts with the state, and (3) the exercise of jurisdiction is reasonable. This is often referred to as the “minimum contacts test.”

Out-of-state tortious conduct by a defendant that causes harm in the forum state has sometimes proven difficult to evaluate under the “purposeful availment” part of the minimum contacts test. On the one hand, the Supreme Court has held that it is not enough that the defendant’s tortious conduct causes injury in the forum state. And, as the Court held in Walden v. Fiore (2014), it is also not enough that the defendant knew about the plaintiffs’ connections to the forum state and knew that its conduct would cause harmful effects there.

On the other hand, in Calder v. Jones (1984), the Court allowed a California actress to sue an out-of-state defendant for defamation based on harm to the plaintiff in the forum state. In Walden the Court reasoned that what matters is the defendant’s contacts with the forum state itself, not the “defendant’s contacts with the persons who reside there.” But in Calder the Court held there was personal jurisdiction in California because the story impugned a California actor and the “brunt of the harm” to her professional reputation was felt there. The Court also noted that the story concerned her California activities, drew on California sources, and appeared in a publication with wide circulation in California.

Allegedly defamatory online content that is available to viewers everywhere is difficult to evaluate under these cases. In Calder, a key point in favor of jurisdiction was the plaintiff’s reputation in California, but under Walden the plaintiff’s location and injury are not enough. Most lower courts have concluded that online publications that are generally available everywhere – even if they allegedly defame a resident of the forum – are not sufficient after Walden, but it is not always clear what additional contacts are necessary to render the defendant’s connection to the forum state purposeful.

Jurisdiction in Florida over the BBC

Trump alleged that the BBC documentary was available and accessible to residents of Florida, that it was actually accessed by residents of Florida, and that BBC intentionally distributed it in the United States. The BBC argued that Trump cannot show that “BBC purposefully aimed the [d]ocumentary at Florida” and that it did not broadcast the documentary in Florida but instead took active steps to prevent access by viewers outside the United Kingdom.

Some of the disagreement between the parties was factual, including the allegations about unauthorized access to the documentary by people in Florida and in the United States as a whole. The opinion makes it a bit difficult to tell which factual disputes were resolved in what way and why, and it does not appear that the court held an evidentiary hearing. The court does “find[]” that Trump is from Florida, that he is the “primary subject of the documentary,” that the BBC “identified Florida as an area of focus during the creation” of the documentary, that the “BBC directly sent a link to Rick Wilson, Florida resident, providing him with the Documentary,” and that the “BBC actively contemplated a global audience, to include an American audience, not just through unauthorized access, but through BBC directing a Documentary about Americans toward Americans broadcast in a window tailored toward the 2024 elections.” A portion of the documentary was apparently filmed in Florida. The court acknowledges that the allegations of unauthorized access in the United States and Florida were contested but seems to credit Trump’s allegation that the BBC sent a link to someone in Florida who was able to access the documentary.

The Florida court correctly held that it had personal jurisdiction over the BBC in my view. Note, however, that in Calder the plaintiff’s professional career and reputation were centered in the California, whereas Trump’s career and reputation are not necessarily centered in Florida. Also, the very small number of Florida citizens who actually viewed the documentary (maybe one? Maybe 35?) also distinguish this case from Calder.  For both reasons, the case is more difficult than Calder itself.

The court’s opinion does not do a great job of clarifying the facts upon which it is based, as mentioned above. For example, the court reasons that the “forum state was placed at issue in the Documentary itself,” which is a powerful point in favor of jurisdiction, but the factual basis for this finding is unclear. The district court also unfortunately applies the “effects test” and the general minimum contacts test as two distinct inquiries, although the effects test is actually just one way of satisfying the broader test that applies in all specific jurisdiction cases. One consequence of using these two tests is that the court invokes Walden only in its separate minimum contacts analysis, even though Walden was itself an effects-test case that narrowed Calder. Here, the court was bound by Eleventh Circuit precedent in Louis Vuitton Malletier v. Mosseri (2013), and dividing the tests up probably did not affect the outcome, although it does make the reasoning more difficult to follow.

Finally, the court reasons that for the BBC to “argue that they never targeted the U.S. presents an unworkable standard. Accepting the BBC’s argument, a foreign litigant would be able to publish false statements directed at a presidential candidate and never be haled into court in the United States, much less Florida.” As compelling as this reasoning may be, it is in tension with J. McIntyre Machinery, Ltd. v. Nicastro (2011). In that case, the plurality insisted that the analysis must proceed sovereign by sovereign, so that a foreign defendant “may in principle be subject to the jurisdiction of the courts of the United States but not of any particular State.” Justice Ginsburg argued in dissent that a foreign manufacturer that targets the U.S. market as a whole should not be able to escape jurisdiction this way, much as the district court reasoned here. But neither the plurality nor the concurrence accepted that argument, and the Court held in Nicastro that New Jersey lacked jurisdiction.

Conclusion

 Some of the conduct alleged in Trump v. BBC raises a question that the Supreme Court noted in Walden but declined to answer: “whether and how a defendant’s virtual ‘presence’ and conduct translate into ‘contacts’ with a particular state.” But much of the key conduct in this case is not related to the Internet. In particular, allegations that the BBC defamed a Florida resident in a documentary that was partly filmed in Florida and that apparently had something to do with Florida itself, and the allegations that BBC sent a link directly to a viewer in Florida, all suggest that the defendants’ conduct was purposefully directed at Florida, regardless of how one resolves broader questions about virtual conduct and personal jurisdiction. In my view, both courts and students tend to think we need new tests for various issues that arise in personal jurisdiction, but this case illustrates that the standard minimum contacts/purposeful availment test works just fine in many situations.